Ahyeon's criticism is 100% valid, but under that logic, almost 90% of current groups should be scrutinized the same way
My unpopular opinion is that as much as I understand why people critizises Ahyeon for overdancing (not underdancing, that's a whole separate can of worms), I really think that by people focusing only on Ahyeon, when there's SO many idols that also dance the same way, and not only is overlooked, but is even praised.
TXT, ATEEZ, KIOF, TripleS (sometimes), BlackPink, BTS, Seventeen, etc. All of the members in these groups all dance like they're trying to tear a limb off by how aggressively and over the top they dance, and at least for me, it not only really takes ayay the experience, it really messes it up. It feel eerie and uncomfortable, and again, it's either overlooked or praised because "it's a display of talent".
I know Ahyeon has much more on her plate than just that, but regardless, if you're gonna bash on her for overdancing (which is what started all of the mess with her) you might as well do it for ALL the groups that does it. I follow some of the groups I mentioned and even stan them, and even I think it's not only unnecessary, but a turnoff. And there's no such excuse like "is stage presence", because you can display good stage presence or energy in general without dancing like there's a centipede in your underwear.
Mostly again, I just think this is unpopular because, once again, people praises or straight up ignores this, but decided to attack Ahyeon specifically and turned her to underdance (not a proper response but still)