Winter vs All Season Tires?

Hi Mechanics! Tire question here!

My winter tires are old (likely 10 years), cracked and last season one of them kept loosing air. I pay to have them stored/ changed and am considering switching to all season tires to cut down on yearly costs. Is this a bad idea? Im guessing new all season tires and better than my 10 year old winter tires?

For context: I have a 2012 Rav4 & live in Toronto, we get only a few big snowy days a year. Would All season work for me? I work from home so I don't have daily long commutes

Also - I know nothing about tires! What are good brands/ what would you recommend?

Thank you!!