Which job offer would my fellow teachers prefer?

Hi everyone! I have been trying to transition out of education for about a year. I’m fortunate enough to have finally received two job offers at the same time—but I’m having a hard time deciding between them.

Offer 1: Salary: $68,000 Commute: 5 minutes Work Environment: 100% in-person for my state government Time Off: 12 PTO days, 12 sick days, 13 holidays Role: Public Relations position that closely aligns with my long-term goal to work in Government Relations

Offer 2: Salary: $56,000 Commute: Fully remote Work Environment: Fully remote Time Off: “Unlimited” PTO Role: Customer Success Manager for a locally based organization, a new and interesting path to explore

Both roles offer great benefits, and I can see myself learning and growing in either. However, they’re very different in terms of work environment and alignment with the sector I’d like to work in in the future. Thank you so much for any feedback you can provide!