Car rentals in 2024

Hi!

I'll be traveling in Sardinia end of October. I've found some older topics about car rentals and most seem to recommend Sardinya and advise to stay clear of bigger (Italian) firms.

Is this still the case? On the Sardinya site I foi d that they made all insurances mandatory for whole 2024 and that seems like a red flag. Or is the traffic that terrible that you're glad to have it?

Thanks!

Edit: I forgot to mention that I will book two child seats as well. Somehow some companies charge 100€ per seat while others cost 35€...