What if RUBY KILLED PENNY instead of Jaune? Would it have been better from a writing perspective?

I think almost all of us agree that killing Penny a second time was a mistake. Why give her a human body if you’re gonna kill her in the next episode? It's like the writers had second thoughts at the last minute.

Another thing that has always bothered me is that it was Jaune who kills her. It’s nothing against him, but I think it would’ve been better and more tragic if it was Ruby, Penny’s first friend, who did it. I think we could’ve had an interesting development for Ruby who learns how to forgive herself for killing Penny.

This is just my opinion of course. What do you think?