Katakuri is far the weakest YC1 we have seen
I wanted to say this after seeing this post , but people really overestimate how strong Katakuri is . He and G4th Luffy were fighting pretty evenly at the end of WCI and we all saw what happened to that Luffy during Act 1 ( dealing no damage to Kaido and then getting one shot ) . Now compare that to the other YC1 commanders we have seen :
Zoro ( who will be our measuring stick for the other commanders ) was able to damage and take hits from both Kaido and Big Mom before even unlocking Conquerors Coating
King dominated the same Zoro that fought on the rooftop and only started taking damage once Zoro unlocked Conquerors Coating and figured out how his flames worked
Marco was able to fight both King and Queen for a significant amount of time and showed only minimal damage ( both dealt and taken )
Now please do tell me how Katakuri , is even on the same level as those 3 , let alone Kidd ( from the post linked at the start ) who's stronger than all of the other 3 ( there's a possible debate for Zoro )