Which one should I get??

Been saving up for weeks, and can now afford a daydreamer! I’ve found two really stunning ones on Vinted but I’m completely torn over which one to go for (Price is not a factor). The black one is in almost perfect condition, but the entire ‘SHOP!” Pocket has peeled. The brown one is completely perfect, zero flaking. But I really prefer the design of the black one…which one’s rarer too? I’d love to hear your input guys! ^{^}